FAQ
Common questions
Piano accordion or diatonic button accordion: which should I get?
Piano accordion if you want to play more than one style or aren't sure yet. It's fully chromatic and handles French musette, Italian folk, tango, pop, or anything else. Diatonic button accordion if you're committed to norteño, Tex-Mex, Cajun, or Irish session music; it's lighter, cheaper, and the standard instrument in those scenes, but essentially unusable outside them.
How heavy is an accordion?
Heavier than they look. A typical 72-bass piano accordion runs 14-18 lbs. Full 120-bass instruments can top 25 lbs. Your back and shoulders will remind you of this on day two. This is one reason we recommend 72-bass over 120-bass for beginners: same capability for beginner repertoire, significantly less weight.
Do I need lessons, or can I learn from a book?
You can get surprisingly far with a good method book plus YouTube, but the bellows mechanics benefit enormously from an in-person eye in the first month. A teacher can see whether you're controlling the bellows from your wrist (bad) or your elbow (correct) in a way a video can't. If possible, take 4-6 lessons in your first two months, then shift to self-directed practice.
How long before I can play a recognizable song?
About a week of daily 20-minute practice sessions. Not well, but recognizably. The accordion is responsive enough that simple melodies fall into place quickly once you stop fighting the bellows. Most beginners play a slow but correct folk melody in their first two weeks.
Why does my accordion go out of tune?
Reeds are tuned individually and they settle with playing. A new accordion played regularly will shift slightly in its first year as the reed cells settle under the wax that holds them. Budget $50-100 for a tuning visit after 6-12 months of regular playing. This is normal maintenance, not a sign you bought a bad instrument.
Is there a big difference between a $400 and a $900 accordion?
Yes, though not always in ways beginners feel immediately. Higher-grade reeds stay in tune longer and produce a fuller sound. Voicing (how each reed sits in its cell) is also more consistent on better instruments. The bigger risk at $400 is buying an unknown brand with no US service network. A mid-range Hohner at $650 is meaningfully better than a mystery import at $400.